Is Web2.0 healthy?
The critics say not. They are so wrong but in one aspect they are right.
In the past, when we dithered, we doodled or watched TV. Now we can express our dithering in a blog. I am doing that now!
All around me I have seen signs today of people dithering
Let’s take the US blogosphere for a moment.
“Let me be clear,” as politicians are wont to say these days. I am not American. But I an infinitely curious about Obama. I watch politics and economics generally and I have a Google Alert for “Obama”. Every day I read anything and everything that is written about Obama! I have an ongoing and thorough sample. This is what I “hear” from America.
America is in a panic
And they are projecting their panic onto Obama. “Obama is dithering,” people cry. Uh-uh. Obama is going like a train. But the bloggers are dithering. Oh, the bloggers are dithering.
Let me explain how I read dithering in the average blog post
- Almost every blog post that I read about Obama ~ for him or against him ~ is tendentious. It is clear that the author has a position that goes something like this. I am uncomfortable about the world and I am uncomfortable in this world. And then they follow that view by a ragbag of ragbag of stuff that Obama did. It’s a jumble of unrelated stuff that reflects what the blogger is feeling. I include the Huff Post in this sweeping generalization.
- The weirdest part about this stream of muddle coming out of the bloggersphere in the US is that bloggers think that something might change when they write what they write. Such narcissism! Their superficial logic goes like this. “Obama is wrong. I say so. Obama will now do what I say is right.” Will he? Do the bloggers really believe they have that power to blackmail change by voicing their ill temper? Or is their logic even more weird? “Obama will not change and so I can carry on being uncomfortable and whinge and whine until eternity?” Become a “whinging pom”? Well why not? Maybe that is the destiny of fading empires.
- I think that the blog posts are a from of dithering. They are a form of dithering as people decide what action to take. I lived in Zimbabwe most of my life and I used to say there that when you start complaining about Mugabe it is time to get a life. I use complaining about Heads of State as my rule of thumb that someone is losing the plot! The complainer doesn’t even know the man (or woman). They have no influence. Their narrative is, and can only be, displacement activity. It is a expression of bad temper, no more or less.
Scared witless by our own decision
- But not all displacement activity is bad. It is good when we recognize dithering as a signal that we are building up to take a decisive step in our own lives. We have made the decision already. That decision is made. But we haven’t taken the first step. The first step scares us silly. So we rant, rave and complain about others!
What is the decision that has scared us so?
- I think a certain amount of dithering is helpful. It helps us muster the energy and commitment for the journey. It helps us say goodbye to what must be left behind. It helps us tidy away what we want to find on our return, much as we tidy an apartment before we leave on holiday. The big question though is what is the decision we have made.
What is going on behind the appearance of sulking?
Writing this, I realize that I should read American blogs with these questions in mind:
- What decision(s) have been made that American bloggers are winding up to put into practice?
- What decisions are they delaying (possibly unwisely)?
- How does their procrastination affect me (and to be frank advantage me?)
- When I act, how will my actions affect them? (They are far away and I am not very important so not very much ~ but the question should be on the general list of questions.)
- When I comment on their blogs (if they let me ~ many are blocked off), what could I say that is useful to their story?
What decisions have been made in the US by the ordinary blogger?
Many seem to be trying out a policy of sulking? But maybe there is something more interesting going on underneath?
So yes, I am dithering. I am writing about American bloggers dithering to avoid doing some tasks of my own. Have I managed to move from futurology to presentology? Have I managed to bring myself to a state of action?
- I think so. Americans (as a rough group) are in the stage of bargaining. In the 5 stage process of grief, they may slip through a period of depression when they realize that they have to start living again. Then hopefully they fall in love again with life as it is. We are close to the end. For people interested in these processes ~ people have take a year since Lehman’s collapsed to get to this point and America had an election in the middle. That might have slowed down the process of adjustment.
- In the meantime, I can try to understand the decision that American bloggers have made but have not yet enacted. What is scaring them silly? When I understand that, I will find their blogs more enjoyable. They will sap my energy less. And I might make some friends along the way.
Great weekend to you!